Want tax & accounting tips and insights?

Sign up for our newsletter.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

Italy's Expanding Tax Gap: Implications and Solutions

Italy's notorious tax evasion issue is escalating beyond prior estimations. According to a government report reviewed by Reuters, unchecked taxes and social contributions surged to a staggering €102.5 billion ($119 billion) in 2022, a notable increase from the previous year's €99 billion.

Image 1

This revelation upends what had been a celebrated slow and steady reduction. Instead, data illustrates a troubling rise starting in 2020, with acceleration thereafter.

A Political Conundrum

Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni finds herself at a crossroads. Despite previous efforts to ease tax enforcement, including raising cash payment limits from €1,000 to €5,000 and offering tax amnesties for debts going back to 2023, criticism ensues. This has led some to argue such measures reward non-compliance, with economists cautioning that leniency could reverse hard-won strides toward accountable financial practices.

"Tax evasion is akin to terrorism," remarked Deputy Economy Minister Maurizio Leo [Reuters] in a parliamentary session in January 2024, highlighting Italy's move to intensify online tracking of unreported income.

The Evolution of Statistics

These adjusted figures emerge from the national statistics agency ISTAT after a 2024 methodological overhaul, uncovering deeper non-compliance than previously disclosed. From 2018 to 2022, Italy's progress in curbing evasion was only €5.9 billion—far less than prior claims of €26 billion.

These numbers hold significant weight not just for domestic politics but also in EU negotiations. Brussels is vigilant about Rome's debt-to-GDP ratio, which hovers around 137%, making tax compliance vital.

Image 3

Comparative European Landscape

Italy's "shadow economy" remains a European outlier, with Eurostat data showing Italians rely on cash more than any major eurozone nation, despite digital payment incentives. Countries like Spain, France, and Germany have reduced their shadow economy since the pandemic, but Italy's figures persistently lag.

While Meloni's government argues for relaxed penalties to spur voluntary compliance, early data suggest limited success. A 2025 study from the University of Bologna indicates voluntary compliance programs recoup merely 35-40% of owed taxes on average.

Future Considerations

In its 2026 budget, the government has proposed another expansive tax amnesty strategy, allowing individuals and businesses to clear outstanding tax obligations without penalties — a move the European Commission deems "fiscally risky."

Image 2

Ultimately, Italy's obstacle extends beyond policy. It's engrained, cultural, and decades in the making, spanning cash-centric tradesmen to under-reported hospitality revenue. This ingrained behavior remains resistant to change.

The swelling €100 billion tax gap is not merely a financial statistic — it signals a looming crisis. The nation's goal to bridge its shadow economy by modernizing enforcement faces potential regression, potentially straining budgets, deterring investors, and sparking EU tensions over fiscal reliability.

Without innovative interventions, Italy's shadow economy may continue casting a long shadow over Europe's fourth-largest economy.

Share this article...
Bryant CPA, LLC Hello there. How can we help?
Welcome to TaxBot. Your smart tax assistant, simplifying deductions and maximizing returns.
Please fill out the form and our team will get back to you shortly The form was sent successfully